Tableau Reference Lines: When Averages Mean Something You Don’t

Statistically Funny: More Than Average Confusion About What Mean Means Mean

Haha! Get it?! Average? MEAN? Okay okay, this is a quick lesson on how Tableau calculates reference lines for averages “under the hood”, depending on the aggregations in your view.

Verifying Default Settings

Something we’ve all needed at some point is a reference line to show the audience what is “average” in a given situation so we can compare overall values to an average. As an example, I’m going to use a generic Superstore Dataset and compare regional sales to an overall average:

Note: I’ve formatted the values to return US dollars and cents so we can check all of our numbers down to the penny. But how do we check that this is the true average regional sales?

Here I have two methods:

#1: In a Table (if you trust the totals)

  1. Start with the sum of sales in the table, add in grand totals:

2. Change the total calculation from SUM to AVERAGE:

3. Compare your values to your original chart:

#2: In a Calculation

  1. Create a FIXED LOD to sum up all regional sales first, then changed the pill’s aggregation to an average (to divide by the number of regions). In other words, this calculation adds up all regional sales, then averages by the number of orders (or rows) per region:

2. Format the pill to currency and voila!

Taking a Closer Look

Okay, so why am I spending my time on this topic? Great question! I’ve found that Tableau’s aggregations might not be doing what you think they are doing. I won’t go as far as say as Tableau’s defaults are wrong necessarily, but you do need to know how Tableau is calculating to ensure your analysis is accurate.

Average Lines on Averages

In my experience, I see this common mistake all too many times – we want to compare AVERAGE sales by region (or some other dimension), and then drop in an average line to show how each region compares to the “Average average sales”:

How do we know what Tableau is doing here? How is it calculating “average” using this reference line? Is it adding up the total sales and dividing by the number of regions? Or is it adding up all of the average sales and dividing by the number of regions? And does it even matter?

Let’s answer each question separately:

How is Tableau calculating the average line when our aggregation is set to “average”?

Answer: According to the editing pane for this reference line, the default aggregation for any average line is set to (surprise!) AVERAGE!

How is it calculating “average” using this reference line? Is it adding up the overall sales and dividing by the number of regions? Or is it adding up all of the average sales and dividing by the number of regions?

Answer: As in the last example, I’ll give you two methods for answering this question:

  1. Using a table, I changed the Sum([Sales]) aggregation to average and had Tableau tell me the overall average (by region). And low and behold, I got a DIFFERENT overall average value:

2. Using a basic calculated field, I calculated the total sum of sales and divided by the number of regions. That is, I summed the data at a row level and divided by the number of regions:

And I found a result that agreed with the table check, but not the original reference line in the visualization!

Does it even matter? Glad you asked.

Answer: It absolutely matters. Because when you take an average of an averaged calculation, you ignore the number of rows (in this case, orders) that were used to calculate that average. Meaning, the average of an average assumes each region had the same number of orders because it adds up all of the averages and divides by the number of regions. This calculation does not result in overall average sales, but rather a number that could be slightly or extremely off, depending on how different your original regional sales regions looked.

So what are we to do if we want to compare average regional sales to overall average sales, by region? Here’s a quick fix:

Change the aggregation in the editing pane for the reference line from “Average” to Total:

This will tell Tableau that you want the reference line to reflect the average sales (by dimension in your view) of the TOTAL sales, not just the average of averages.

Averaging Percents: Don’t Do It!

You don’t want to average percents for the same reason as above. Percents are calculated from ratio, just like averages, so the mistake is the same — the total number of rows used for each individual regional percent (in this case profit ratio) differ because there are a different number of orders (rows) in each region.

So the workaround is the same — you’ll want to create a reference line based on overall profit ratio (or “total”), not an average of the percents in your view to get the correct value for your reference line:

You’ll see a big jump now from the incorrect overall profit ratio of 10.8%, which was calculated as an average of the profit ratios in our view, to the correct overall profit ratio of 10.1%:

Hope this helps as you navigate all of the self-service goodies Tableau has to offer without fumbling the analysis.

From Data to a Story

Photo by Markus Spiske on

To be fair, there are probably thousands of people more qualified to write about Data Storytelling than I. Though since it’s a topic I love and a topic I teach I will do my best to cover a few points for the curious in this post – especially the overlooked step of FINDING the data story.

What is Data?

You can Google the definition of data and find a slew of different answers, but one simplistic way to think about data is how my favorite Statistics textbook defines the term: “Data are usually numbers, but they are not ‘just numbers.’ Data are numbers with context.” (Yates, et al. The Practice of Statistics 3rd Edition.) So when we pull quantitative variables and qualitative (categorical) variables together, we are essentially giving meaning to what was otherwise a set of lonely numerical values.

I received some great answers to this tweet here.

What is Data Storytelling?

In my humble opinion, data storytelling takes the data (aka numbers in context) and, not only translates it into consumable information, but creates a connection between the audience and the insights to drive some action. That action might be a business decision or a “wow, I now appreciate this topic” response, depending on the context and audience.

A Short Guide to Data Storytelling

There are a few steps to telling a data story, and they could get complicated depending on your data type and analysis. And since your and your audience’s interests, background, and ability to draw conclusions plays into your storytelling, this process of finding and telling a data story could easily detour and fall into rabbit holes. Here I will map out a few general steps for both exploratory and explanatory analysis to help you simplify the complex both in process and in message.

1. Define Your Audience and Determine Their Objectives

This is important. And you’ll need to continue circling back to your audience throughout all of the steps below. If you know your audience’s goals, you can more easily cancel out the noise in your data and define the right questions and metrics along the way.

2. Find the Data Story: Exploratory Analysis

a) Make a Picture

To tell a data story, you have to find the data story. And that begins with the exploratory analysis of your dataset – which should always begin with exploring your data visually. When I taught AP Stats I told the students the same thing I tell you now: When you get your hands on a set of data, MAKE A PICTURE. There are so many things a chart or graph (or multiple charts and graphs) can tell you about the data that tables and summary statistics cannot (including errors). See Anscombe’s Quartet for a demonstration of WHY.

Here I have a dataset from Wikipedia – Ironman World Championship Medalists. I must give credit to Eva Murray and Andy Kriebel for putting this data into .csv form for a 2019 Makeover Monday challenge .

What story can we tell about this data from this format? It’s possible to draw some conclusions based on patterns we might be able to pull with our eyes; however, nothing exact and nothing conclusive. Instead, you might use data visualization tools to create charts and graphs — something like Tableau or Excel, or if you have time on your hands, a whiteboard and dry erase markers — to tease out a story.

b) Ask Questions. And Keep Asking Questions.

So where do you start? I always start with questions. Like, “Which countries have had the most medals in the Ironman Championship?”

We can also ask, “Which countries are the fastest, on average?” I’ve sorted low to high to reflect the fastest countries on top (faster = shorter duration):

Oh that is interesting – I did not expect to see the US at the bottom of the list given they have the most medals in the dataset. But since I looked at all medals and did not only consider GOLD medals, I might now want to compare countries with the most gold medals. It’s possible the US won mostly bronze, right?

Interesting! I did NOT expect to see the US at the top of this chart after my last analysis. Hmmmm…

c) Don’t Assume, Ask “Why?”

And as you continue to ask questions, you’ll pull out more interesting insights. Since the distribution of gold medals looks similar to the distribution of all medals, I’m still quite curious why the average times for the US is higher than other countries when they have an overwhelmingly large number of gold medals (and gold medals = fastest times). There MUST be some other variable confounding this comparison. So now I’ll slice the data by other variables — now I’ll look at gender, and compare the overall average finish times of males vs females:

So if males are, on average, faster than females then maybe we should look at the breakdown of males vs females among countries. Is it possible the distribution of males and females differ by country?

Note: Since this is a stacked bar chart, it may appear that the graph is unsorted; however, when there are two genders present, the length of the bar represents the sum of both the overall average male finish times and overall average female finish times. The chart is still sorted by overall average time, as you see 2 charts above.

Hmmm, it looks like the top countries, by average time, are represented by male athletes only. Meanwhile, females, whose times are slightly slower than males, make up a large proportion of the remaining countries.

Since the above chart is comparing average race times, let’s bring in some counts to compare the number (and ultimately proportion) of male vs female athletes in each country.

Alright, so now it makes sense that the overall average time for countries with a large proportion of female medalists will appear slightly longer than those with only males. Next I’d like to compare male and female finish times for ONLY gold medalists:

Wow, interesting! Of the 9 countries with gold medals, 8 of them have female representation on the 1st place podium. And 4 of those 9 countries ONLY have female representation at gold. But this doesn’t explain why the US has taken home so many more gold medals than other countries, while the overall average finish times for US finishers (and gold medalists too) are slower! What’s going on?

Is the YEAR a factor? When did the US win gold medals?

In the above graph, each country is now represented by a line graph (or two lines, if they both females and males won gold medals for that country). But I’ve changed the red color to highlight the US and shades of gray to put the other countries in the background. Looking at the above graph, we can see the overall finish times have decreased over time. AND we can see the US, for both males AND females, haven’t won gold medals in over a decade. So the two confounding variables we found for the race time paradox, as we could call it, were both gender AND year.

d) Focus on One Story

At this point I need to narrow down my context and define what questions I want to ask and which metrics will answer those questions. It’s hard to listen to someone’s story when it has a million tangents, right? So don’t tell those meandering stories with data, either. Pick a topic – and don’t forget to consider your audience. I’ve decided to step away from the specific countries, and compare only those GOLD MEDAL race times by gender over time. I’m curious to learn more about WHY those finish times fell over time!

e) Find the Right Analysis for Your Story

Once you determine which variables are involved in your analysis, you can choose the appropriate chart to dig deeper into the insights. Because I chose to focus on gold medal finish times over the years, a time series analysis is appropriate. Here is a great reference tool for matching your analysis to your questions:

Let’s bring in years and create a timeline:

And clearly there is more to investigate here – like why, if I stick with Tableau’s default aggregation of SUM do I see a spike here? After some Googling – ah, that year TWO separate Ironman Championships were held. So even though I’m looking only at times for the male and female gold medal times, there’s one year that’s doubled because there are two gold medal times per gender. Easy fix, let’s change the aggregation to AVERAGE, which will only affect this one year. Now let’s tease out our big story by looking at our chart and asking more questions :

3. Explanatory Analysis

Once you’ve explored the data and you’ve asked and (tried to) answer questions arising from the analysis, you’re ready to pull the story together for your audience.

a) Design with the Audience in Mind

Without calling attention to it, I began this step above. As you can see, I changed up the colors in my charts when I brought in the variable of gender. I did this for you, my audience, so you could easily pick out the differences in the race times for males and females. This is called “leveraging pre-attentive attributes“, which basically means here I’ve used color to help you see the differences without consciously thinking about it. In my final version I will need to make sure the difference in gender is clear and easy to compare (more on this later).

Color also needs to be chosen with the audience in mind. Not only do the colors need to make sense (here I chose the Iron Man brand colors to distinguish gender), they also need to be accessible for all viewers. For example the colors chosen need to have enough contrast for people with color vision deficiency. (For more in-depth information about the use of color, Lisa Charlotte Rost has an excellent resource in her blog Data Wrapper.) Too much of a good thing is never a good thing, so I chose to keep all other colors in the chart neutral so other elements of the story do not compete for the audience’s attention.

Also, without telling you, I’ve stripped away some of the unnecessary “clutter” in my chart by dumping grid lines and axis lines. When in doubt, leave white space in your charts to maximize the “data-to-ink ratio” – save your ink for the data and skip the background noise when possible.

Finally, I’m sticking with my old standard font (Georgia) for the axes and (eventually in the final version, the title). A serif typeface, Georgia is easy to read on small screens or screens with low resolution.

b) Call Attention to the Story/Insights/Action

Here I’ve answered a couple of questions that arose from the data, and you, my audience, never had to switch tabs to go looking for answers. (Re-reading my words I feel like I must sound like Grover in The Monster at the End of the Book.)

That increase in race time in 1981? A course change! Only a slight increase in time for males, but a big slow down for the females.

Also note I included an annotation for the two races in 1982.

It’s interesting to see the steady decline in finish times throughout the 1980s — what might have caused this decline? And remember, a decline in finish times means GOLD MEDALISTS GOT FASTER.

And finally, I called attention to the spike in 2004. Apparently the gold medal finisher was DQ’ed for doping…which makes me wonder about the sharp decline in the 1980’s.

c) Leverage the Title

In the words of Kurt Vonnegut, Pity the Readers. Be as clear and concise and don’t assume they understand your big words and complicated jargon. Keep it simple! One thing I left out of my original title was the very specific use of ONLY gold medal data here. Without that information, the reader might think we were averaging all of the medalist’s times each year!

But is it clear what the red and black colors mean? And are there any additional insights I can throw into my title without being verbose?

Color legends take up dashboard space and I’m a bit keen on the white space I’ve managed to leave in my view. In my final version, I’ve colored the words MALE and FEMALE in the subtitle to match the colors used in the chart, serving as a simple color legend.

A subtitle can help guide the audience to a specific insight, in this case the overall decline in gold medal times by both males and females since the first Ironman World Championship in 1978.

Other Considerations

My final version is interactive, as you can see here. I’ve added notes to the tooltip to display the percent change in winning times by gender each year when the audience interacts with the chart:

If you’re using multiple charts for your data story, you’ll also want to consider layout and how the audience will likely consume that information. Tableau has an excellent article on eye-tracking studies to help data story designers create a flow with minimal cognitive load and maximum impact.

Other Data Storytelling Resources

Storytelling with Data – Cole Nussbaumer Knaflic

Info we Trust – RJ Andrews

Data Storytelling: The Ultimate Collection of Resources

How to Adapt: Resources for Digital Instruction

One of the most influential mentors and leaders in my adult life is the spirited Keith Ball. Mr. Ball, or “KB” as he’s widely known, was the principal of the school at which I taught for 5 years (years 9 – 13 of my teaching career). I’ll never forget Keith’s messages on leadership, education, and responsibility. On repeat he’d remind us teachers that it is our job to BE ADAPTABLE.

E-instruction is VERY DIFFERENT from in-person instruction! And since many educators, including those of us in the L&D world, are now creating digital plans to deliver training, I thought I would compile (and update) resources from around the education, LMS, and L&D world in one place.


“Maslow before Bloom”

Love this quick synopsis by Angela Gibson:

Even if you’re not completely new to e-instruction an instructional design, I recommend starting with this webinar from Karen Costa and Clea Mahoney. In addition to an outline of what it looks like to meet people where they are, improve presentation skills, tools for feedback, a lesson planning template and more!


Personally, my experience with online learning platforms is limited to Zoom Meeting, GoToTraining, WebEx, and Canvas (Instructure). Each platform has its pros and cons, so look into what is important to you and your students before making this decision. See the bottom of this post for free webinars on the use of Zoom.

Be sure to teach your students how to use the platform you’re using before you get into the meat of your course! Don’t assume they know how to interact online.

Shifting to E-Instruction

I can’t stress enough how different digital instruction is to in-person teaching! You definitely have to plan it out in a similar way, but pacing, tone of voice, and even the activities you choose will be different from your typical delivery. Spending some time preparing using a lesson plan template to help organize your time and think through your essential questions, activities, and formative assessments.


I spent some time on the phone this morning with one of my oldest and dearest friends. Rachel is a an instructional designer and a long-time digital instructor for Power School. I asked her if she’d help me with tips for instructors teaching virtually for the first time. At the moment I’m typing this, she’s still sending me texts as she thinks of more tips – so come back later and you’ll most likely find this list has grown:

  • Keep it moving, but not racing
  • Don’t leave dead time for hands-on activities. If it takes less time than you planned, get it moving.
  • Don’t navigate too quickly from one page to the next. There’s always a time lag and while you’re saying, “Click here, then there” and simultaneously doing that, people’s screens haven’t caught up.

Planning Activities

First determine what capabilities your learning platform provides. Break-out rooms, polls, chat boxes, and mini quizzes are just some of the possibilities, depending on the platform. Then use the lesson plan you’ve been using to determine which capabilities can be used to engage the learners. Examples:

  • At the beginning of the course, have every student write something in the chat box – something personal. For example, “Where are you located?” or “What is the nearest object to your left?” You’ll get a feel for the pulse of the room and set up expectations for an interactive learning environment from the beginning.
  • You’ve just taught the entire group a new use for a concept or tool we’ll call “X”. Use break-out rooms for participants of similar job functions to discuss one or two ways of how they can immediately implement X when they return to their desk. POP IN on the break out rooms and ask a question – you want to hold participants accountable.
  • Have participants share screens. But share the love, don’t ask the same person each time even if they are the only one willing.
  • Don’t forget to keep using the chat box to gauge the room.
  • Post polls (uploaded/created ahead of time). These can be used as immediate feedback for you and the participants if you create simple multiple choice questions “quizzing” them on a concept they just learned.
  • Have a white board in your office? Use it! Have a collaborative session where participants throw out ideas. Stand up, write them down on that white board! Just because you aren’t in the same room doesn’t mean you can’t move around like you would in a typical training room.
  • Kahoot! is a fun way to game your topic – and give the participants a break. While it’s free for educators, there is a charge for business. Setting up the quiz on the front end is simple and participants can play from their browser OR their phone.

During Instruction

More from Rachel Ogg:

  • Use a mouse cursor large enough for participants to see easily. Steer clear of that big, round, yellow highlight cursor. It can be distracting and, more importantly, it hides everything behind it.
  • When you ask learners questions, give them time to answer, especially if you’re asking them to chat their answers. It takes time to type. Also, if folks will only be chatting their answers (as opposed to speaking them aloud), try and ask questions that require short-ish responses.
  • Call on specific people to do something or show you something. This increases learner attention. Be sure to tell them from the outset you’ll be doing this.

Train the Trainer Resources

The Bob Pike Group offers training bootcamps to get your trainers up to speed on virtual delivery. Their website also provides multiple resources for e-instruction such as webinars, a blog, and guides.

The Association for Talent Development also provides multiple webinars for virtual interactions, including how to convert your classroom to a virtual environment and openers and checklists for facilitators.

eLearning Guild is packed FULL of resources for the e-learning instructor. Start with a free guide to Getting Started in eLearning.

More Resources

10 Tips for Giving Effective Virtual Presentations

Check back later for more!!

Struggling with Uncertainty : The Role of Variability

“Uncertainty is the only certainty there is, and knowing how to live with insecurity is the only security.”
― John Allen Paulos

What is Uncertainty and Why Does it Matter?

At a high level, “uncertainty” is the unknown. You might believe it’s as abstract as chaos, but in fact a truth does exist – a “true” value, or parameter is out there – we just don’t know it. In fact, uncertainty is a certainty when working with data. We use samples of data in time to make decisions on the current and future state of business. And to look for truths in data, we often estimate or use probability to attempt to capture that value, or ranges of values, based on known data/observations.

I teach people how to work with, understand, and garner insights from data. What I’ve also noticed there are two kinds of clients I’ve come across in the consulting world:

  1. Those who would like to learn HOW to visualize, measure, and understand uncertainty to help make better organizational decisions.
  2. Those who have never considered the impact of uncertainty on organizational decisions.

As I suggested above, working with uncertainty starts with working with sample sets of data – whatever we can get our hands on. From our observed data, we can make generalizations about a phenomenon or event that may impact our organization by estimating the probability they will occur. We do this with point estimates, intervals, or broad language. For example:

  • Mr. X has a 40% chance of becoming the new CEO.
  • The proportion of revenue expected to come from our small business division this quarter is approximately 54%, with a 3% margin of error.
  • The Pacific Region will likely merge with the North Pacific Region next year.

Building probability models to uncover these predictions is another conversation for another day; however, it is possible to take a baby step towards understanding uncertainty and working with probabilities. In my opinion, the first step on that journey is learning more about how we interpret variation/variability in data. Why? Because accuracy and precision in measuring a probability depends on how well we’ve measured and contained the variability in the data. How we interpret probabilities depends on how we understand the difference between significance, and natural variation.


From Merriam-Webster:

Definition of variation 

  1. the act or process of varying the state or fact of being varied
  2. an instance of varying
  3. the extent to which or the range in which a thing varies

Ah. Isn’t that helpful?

kevin hart

Google, save me!


  1. A change or difference in condition, amount, or level, typically with certain limits
  2. A different or distinct form or version of something


lack of consistency or fixed pattern; liability to vary or change.

Why Does Variation Matter?

Here’s the thing — there’s no need to study/use data when everything is identical. It’s the differences in everything around us that creates this need to use, understand, and communicate data. Our minds like patterns, but a distinction between natural and meaningful variation is not intuitive – yet it is important.

Considering how often we default to summary statistics in reporting, it’s not surprising that distinguishing between significant insights and natural variation is difficult. Not only is it foreign, the game changes depending on your industry and context.

What’s So Complicated About Variation?

Let’s set the stage to digest the concept of variation by identifying why it’s not an innate concept.

At young ages, kids are taught to look for patterns, describe patterns, predict the next value in a pattern. They are also asked, “which one of these is not like the other?”

But this type of thinking generally isn’t cultivated or expanded. Let’s look at some examples:

1) Our brains struggle with relative magnitudes of numbers.

large numbers

We have a group of 2 red and 2 blue blocks. Then we start adding more blue blocks. At what point do we say there are more blue blocks? Probably when there are 3 blue, 2 red, right?

Instead, what if we started with 100 blocks? Or 1000? 501 red/499 still seems the same, right? Understanding how the size of the group modifies the response is learned – as sample/population size increases, variability ultimately decreases.

Something to ponder: When is $300 much different from $400? When is it very similar?

“For example, knowing that it takes only about eleven and a half days for a million seconds to tick away, whereas almost thirty-two years are required for a billion seconds to pass, gives one a better grasp of the relative magnitudes of these two common numbers.”
― John Allen Paulos, Innumeracy: Mathematical Illiteracy and Its Consequences

We understand that 100 times 10 is 1000. And mathematically, we understand that 1 Million times 1000 is 1 Billion. What our brains fail to recognize is the difference between 1000 and 100 is only 900, but the difference between 1 million and 1 billion is 999,000,000! We have trouble with these differences in magnitudes:


We kind of “glaze” over these concepts in U.S. math classes. But they are not intuitive!

2) We misapply the Law of Large Numbers

My favorite example misapplying the Law of Large Numbers is called The Gambler’s Fallacy, or Monte Carlo Fallacy. Here’s an easy example:

Supposed I flip a fair coin 9 times in a row and it comes up heads all 9 times, what is your prediction for the 10th coin flip? If you said tails because you think tails is more likely, you just fell for the Gambler’s Fallacy. In fact, the probability for each coin flip is exactly the same each time AND each flip is independent of another. The fact that the coin came up heads 9 times in a row is not known to the coin, or gravity for that matter. It is natural variation in play.

The Law of Large Numbers does state that as the number of coin flips increase (n>100, 1000, 10000, etc), the probability of heads gets closer and closer to 50%. However, the Law of Large numbers does NOT play out this way in the short run — and casinos cash in on this fallacy.

Oh, and if you thought the 10th coin flip would come up heads again because it had just come up heads 9 times before, you are charged with a similar fallacy, called the Hot Hand Fallacy.

3) We rely too heavily on summary statistics


Once people start learning “summary statistics”, variation is usually only brought in as a discussion as a function of range. Sadly, range only considers minimum and maximum values and ignores any other variation within the data. Learning beyond “range” as a measure of variation/spread also helps hone in on differences between mean and median and when to use each.

Standard deviation and variance also measure variation; however, the calculation relies on the mean (average) and when there is a lack of normality to the data (e.g. the data is strongly skewed), standard deviation and variance can be an inaccurate measure of the spread of the data.

In relying on summary statistics, we find ourselves looking for that one number – that ONE source of truth to describe the variation in the data. Yet, there is no ONE number that clearly describes variability – which is why you’ll see people using the 5-number summary and interquartile range. But the lack of clarity in all summary statistics makes the argument for visualizing the data.

When working with any kind of data, I always recommend visualizing the variable(s) of interest first. A simple histogram, dot plot, or box-and-whisker plot can be useful in visualizing and understanding the variation present in the data.


Start Simple: Visualize Variation

Before calculating and visualizing uncertainty with probabilities, start with visualizing variation by looking at the data one variable at a time at a granular or dis-aggregated level.

Box-and-whisker can, not only give show you outliers, these charts can also give a comparison of consistency within a variable:

variation box and whiskers

Simple control charts can capture natural variation for high-variability organizational decision-making, such as staffing an emergency room:

variation control chart

Think of histograms as a bar graph for continuous metrics. Histograms show the distribution of the variable (here, diameters of tortillas) over a set of bins of the same width. The width of the bar is determined by the “bin size” – smaller sets of ranges of tortilla diameters – and the height of the bar measures the frequency, or how many tortillas measured within that range. For example, the tallest bar indicates there are 26 tortillas measuring between (approximately) 6.08 and 6.10 cm.

I can’t stress enough the importance of changing the bin size to explore the variation further.

variation histograms

Notice the histogram with the wider bin size (below) can hide some of the variation you see above. In fact, the tortillas sampled for this process came from two separate production lines- which you can conclude from the top histogram but not below, thus emphasizing the importance of looking at variability from a more granular level.

variation histogram wide


Recently, Storytelling with Data blogged about visualizing variability. I’m also a fan of Nathan Yau’s Flowing Data post about visualizing uncertainty.

Brittany Fong has a great post about disaggregated data, as well as Steve Wexler’s post on Jitter Plots.

I plan a follow-up post diving more into probabilities and uncertainty. For now, I’m going to leave you with this cartoon from XKCD, called “Certainty.


How to be the Life of the Party Part 3: Permutations and Combinations

(and why your locker combination is actually a permutation)

Welcome to the third installment of my Cheat Sheet for Stats. Be sure to check out Part 1 and Part 2.

Permutations and combinations are useful to someone interested in determining the total number of items from a set or group. This is especially helpful in probability when calculating a denominator and/or numerator.

The difference between a permutation and a combination is simple to understand – if you pay close attention to how the items/objects/people are chosen (and ignore semantics). In this post I’ll give you definitions, formulas, and examples of both permutations and combinations. But first, I’ll discuss the Fundamental Counting Principle and factorials.

The Fundamental Counting Principle

Also known as the multiplication counting rule, this principle says to multiply all possible events together to find the total number of outcomes.

A simple example starts with packing for a vacation. Say you pack 4 shirts, 3 pairs of pants, and 2 pairs of shoes. How many possible outfits can you make? (Assume they all match, or you are 5 years old and don’t give a flip.)

The fundamental counting principle says you now have:

4 * 3 * 2 = 24 possible outfits

Here’s another example. Let’s say your company requires a 5-value verification code consisting of 3 numerical values and 2 alphabetic values (in that order and case sensitive). How many possible verification codes can be produced?

Sometimes it helps to see what is going on:

And visualize the values in each position:

There are 10 total digits to consider (0 – 9) and 26 letters in the alphabet – 52 if case-sensitive. The trick is to multiply to find the total possible outcomes:

= 2,704,000 different verification codes

And what if the requirement changed to 3 numbers and 2 letters (same order), but no repeats? We’d have to take away the number of options for each digit/letter as they are used:

= 1,909,440 different verification codes

There is a little more math involved if you can put these values in any order and I won’t cover that in this post.


At first glance, a factorial looks like a very excited number. For instance, 5! might appear to be yelling, “FIVE!” (Silly teacher joke – works better in person.) The exclamation point is actually an operator telling us to multiply that number by all integers less than that number down to 1.

Image result for factorial meme


Permutations apply the Fundamental Counting Principle to determine the number of ways you can arrange members of a group. The permutation formula calculates the number of arrangements of n objects taken r at a time:

For example, let’s say you and 29 other people are in the running for 3 distinct prizes. Your names are in a hat and prizes are only given to the first, second, and third names drawn (the best prize being first). The number of ways 30 people can take first, second, and third prize is called a permutation. In a permutation, the order in which the items or people are arranged “matters”. (And by matters, you could say the order is noted, or apparent.)

don’t judge my looks, I just ran a 5K in 25:36. the first place winner didn’t show up for her prize so a nice lady held the sign so we didn’t look like chumps.

For the prize example, you can calculate this using the formula for permutations:

And this goes back to the fundamental counting principle since a portion of the numerator cancels with the denominator:

Simplifying the expression to 30*29*28 = 24,360 ways 3 individuals can be awarded first, second, and third prize from a group of 30 in a random drawing. If we were merely drawing 3 names all at once with no difference in prizes, it would NOT be considered a permutation.

Luckily you really don’t need to know the formula to calculate a permutation. The Excel function for permutations is PERMUT:

Note: There is another Excel function for permutations with repetitions – that one is PERMUTATIONA. For this example, you would use that if we drew names for the three prizes and each time the name was returned to the hat, making it possible for the same person to win all 3 times.


Now suppose you and 29 other individuals are in the running for 3 prizes, all with the same value. Your names are in a hat and all three names are drawn at once. Because no order or arrangement is involved, this type of counting technique is called a combination. The combination formula also calculates n objects taken r at a time:

notice the denominator is different – and since you’re dividing by a larger number you can see that a combination will produce fewer possible groups than will a permutation

For the newest version of our prize example, we are taking 3 names from the hat at one time and there is no difference between prizes. Here is that calculation:

Once the 27! in the numerator and denominator cancel, we are left with the 24,360 in the numerator, but still divide by 3! (which is 3*2 = 6):

Which results in only 4060 possible combinations.

The Excel function for combinations is COMBIN:

A Locker Combination is Actually a Permutation

Combination Padlock, Not Resettable Center-Dial Location, 3/4" Shackle Height

Now consider locker combinations. Let’s assume a typical dial lock (Right, left, right) in which there are 39 numbers on the dial and your code has 3 numbers. Does order matter? Absolutely! If you try to open the lock using your 3 number code but in a different order, the locker will not open. So how many possible codes does this locker have?

If numbers couldn’t repeat, we’d have P(39,3) = 54,834 different codes (or what we call “combinations”). But if numbers could repeat, there are 39*39*39 = 59,319 possible codes – to include repeatable values, apply the PERMUTATIONA function in Excel.

You Try!

Based on what you just learned, can you spot the difference between a combination and permutation? Bonus points if you can calculate the result. (Answers at the end of the post.)

  1. A board of directors consists of 13 people. In how many ways can a chief executive officer, a director, and a treasurer be selected?
  2. How many ways can a jury of 12 people be selected from a group of 40 people?
  3. A GM from a restaurant chain must select 8 restaurants from 14 for a promotional program. How many different ways can this selection be done?
  4. At Waffle House hash browns can be ordered 18 different ways. How possible orders can be made by choosing only 3 of the 18?
  5. A locker can have a 4-digit code. How many different codes can we have if there are 25 different numbers and numbers cannot repeat in any given code?


  1. Permutation. P(13,3) = 1716
  2. Combination. C(40,12) = 5,586,853,480 order isn’t important here
  3. Combination. C(14,8) = 3003
  4. Combination. C(18,3) = 816
  5. Permutation. P(25,4) = 303,600 (Repeating numbers within a code would give 390,625 different codes.)

How to be the Life of the Party Part 2: Measures of Position

Welcome to Part 2 of my Cheat Sheet for Stats series, sure to make you the life of the party! In case you missed it, Part 1 covered measures of center and spread. In Part 2 we’ll dive into measures of position and location within a dataset – specifically how to calculate, apply, and interpret them.

Measures of Position

Comparing month to month sales volume or current housing prices within your neighborhood are easy to make without involving additional calculations. However, sometimes metrics aren’t exactly comparable in absolute terms. For example, sales volume from 1989 versus 2015. Or current housing prices in Atlanta versus San Francisco. So we typically “normalize” these metrics by adjusting for inflation or cost of living so we can compare relative values.

Another way of comparing considers relative position. Percentiles, quantiles, and z-scores measure the location of a value in relation to other values in a dataset. Once you know the price of a house in Atlanta relative to the rest of the Atlanta housing market, and the price of a house in San Francisco relative to the rest of the San Francisco housing market, you can see how those two housing prices compare to each other.


Percentiles describe the position of a data point relative to the rest of the dataset using a percent. That’s the percent of the rest of the dataset that falls below the particular data point.

Finding an Unknown Percentile

Example: Pretend you’re the 2nd oldest out of a group of 20 people. To find your percentile, count the number of people YOUNGER than you (18) and divide by the total number of people:

18/20 = 0.9, or the 90th percentile

(Note: By calculating percentile using the “percent less than” formula above, the computation disallows a 100th percentile (which is not a valid percentile); however, it forces the lowest value to the 0 percentile (which is also invalid). Another popular variation on this calculation computes the percent less than AND equal to: There are 19 people at your age or younger, so 19/20 is 95th percentile. This version of the calculation fixes the “0 percentile” problem but allows the possibility for an invalid 100th percentile. Both versions of the percentile calculation are acceptable and there is no universally “correct” computation.)

Finding a Given Percentile

Example: You want to determine what height marks the 58th percentile of the 20 people. You’ll multiply the 20 people by 58%, or 20*(0.58) = 11.6. This number is called the index. Round to the nearest whole number 12 – therefore, the 12th height in your group of 20 people roughly falls at the 58th percentile.

A cumulative relative frequency chart, used to locate percentiles


Quantiles break the dataset up into an equal number of n pieces. They signal reference points (or positions) in the dataset to which individual data points can be compared. Specific examples of quantiles are deciles (slicing the data into 10 equal pieces), terciles (3 equal pieces), and quartiles (4 equal pieces). I’ll elaborate using quartiles, but all quantiles follow the same logic:


Quartiles break the dataset up into 4 equal pieces so data points can be compared within the dataset relative to the four quarters of data.

I love watching football, which is broken up into four quarters. If I turn the TV on and the game has already started, I know how far the game has progressed in time relative to the quarter displayed on the screen.

For data:

  • Lower Quartile (Q1) – Roughly the 25th percentile. 25% of the data falls below this point and 75% lies above.
  • Median (Q2) – Roughly the 50th percentile, marks the position of the middle value where half fall above and half fall below this point
  • Upper Quartile (Q3) – Roughly the 75th percentile. 75% of the data falls below this point and 25% lies above.

Quartiles are found using these steps:

  1. Arrange the data from least to greatest.
  2. Find the median, the middle number. (If there are two numbers in the middle, find the average of the two.)
  3. Using the median as the midpoint, the data is now split in half. Now find the middle value in the bottom half of values (this is Q1).
  4. Lastly, find the middle number of the top half of values (this is Q3).

Example: The following values represent the lifespan of a sample of animals. What values break these lifespans into quartiles?

Often quartiles are displayed visually with a box-and-whisker plot:

Full blog post on box-and-whisker plots HERE


A z-score indicates how many standard deviations a value falls above or below the mean (average). A value with a positive z-score lies above the mean while a value with a negative z-score falls below the mean. Z-scores are a way of standardizing values in order to compare them using relative position.

To calculate a z-score, subtract the average of the population/dataset (mean) from the data point (observation), then divide by the standard deviation of the population/dataset:


In 1927, Babe Ruth made history hitting 60 home runs in one Major League Baseball season. Only four people have been able to break Ruth’s record (though Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa have broken that record 2 and 3 times, respectively). In 2001, Barry Bonds set the most recent record, hitting 73 home runs in a single season.

But just how does Barry’s home run performance compare to Babe’s? Many outside factors such as bat quality and pitcher performance could impact the number of homeruns hit by a MLB player. So how did these athletes compare to their peers of the time?

The 1927 league home run average was 7.2 home runs with a standard deviation of 9.7 home runs. While the 2001 league average was an astounding 21.4 home runs, with a standard deviation of 13.2 home runs.

To properly compare these heavy hitters, we need to determine how they preformed relative to the peers of their era by standardizing their absolute HR numbers into z-scores:

Babe Ruth’s performance of 60 HRs lies 5.44 standard deviations above the mean number of HRs hit in 1927
Barry Bond’s performance of 73 HRs lies 3.91 standard deviations above the mean number of HRs hit in 2001

While both athletes displayed phenomenal performances, Babe Ruth could still argue his status of home run champion when comparing in relative terms.

If you automatically think of a bell-shaped, normal curve when you hear “z-score”, you’re not alone. That’s a common connection because of the way we initially introduce z-scores in stats courses:

But z-scores can apply to ANY distribution because they are a way to compare data values using relative position. That is, z-scores “standardize” the data values from absolute to relative metrics.

The Altman Z-score

The Altman z-score is used to predict the liklihood a company will go bankrupt. The Altman z-score applies a weighted calculation based on specific predictors of bankruptcy. This article gives an excellent overview for those interested in calculating and interpreting Altman z-scores.

Next up in Part 3: Counting principles, including permutations and combinations. Because the combination for your combination lock is actually a permutation.

How to be the Life of the Party Part 1: A Cheat Sheet to Summary Statistics

Statistics: What are they good for?

Statistics are values or calculations that attempt to summarize a sample of data. If you’re talking about a population of data, you’re usually dealing with parameters. (Easy to remember: Statistics and Samples start with the letter S, and Populations and Parameters start with the letter P.)

And if you know all there is to know about a population, then you wouldn’t be concerned with statistics. However, we almost never know about an entire population of anything, which is why we focus on studying samples and the statistics that describe those samples.

Statistics and summary statistics, as I mentioned, help us summarize a sample of data so that we can wrap our mind around the entire dataset. Some statistics are better than others, and which statistic you choose to summarize a dataset depends entirely upon the type of data you’re working with and your end goals.

Here, I will briefly discuss the different types, definitions, calculations, and uses of basic summary statistics known as “Measures of Central Tendency” and “Measures of Variation.”

Measures of Central Tendency

Measures of central tendency summarize your dataset into one “typical”, central value. It’s best to look at the shape of your data and your ultimate goals before choosing one measure of central tendency.


The mean, or average is affected by extreme (outlying) measures since, mathematically, it takes into account all values in the dataset.

Suppose you want to find the mean, or average, of 5 runners on your running team:

The average function in Excel is AVERAGE.


x-bar is the mean of the sample
mu is the mean of the population


Instead of taking the value of the numbers into account, the median considers which value(s) take the middle position. Outliers do NOT affect the value of the median.

The median function in Excel is MEDIAN.


The most common value, category, or quality is the mode. The mode measures “typical” for categorical data.

In quantitative data, we look for modal ranges to help us dig deeper and segment the dataset. I wrote a blog post recently that dives a little deeper into this concept, as well as visualizing measures of central tendency.

The mode function in Excel is MODE.

Weighted Mean

A weighted mean is helpful when all values in the dataset do not contribute to the average in the same way. For example, course grades are weighted based on what the type of assignment (test, quiz, project, etc). A test might count more towards your final grade than a homework assignment.

Weighted means are also applied when calculating the expected value of an outcome, such as in gambling and actuarial science. An expected value in gambling is what you’d expect to lose (because you’re gonna lose) over the long-run (many, many trials). To calculate this, a probability is applied to each possible outcome and then multiplied by the value of the outcome — pretty much the same way you calculated your grade back in high school:

Note: Weighted Means and Expected Values will reappear in a later post discussing discrete probability distributions.

I wrote a more extensive blog post about “other” means, including Geometric and Harmonic means, in case you’re curious.

Measures of Variation

The middle number of the dataset is only one statistic used the summarize the dataset — the spread of the data is also extremely important to understanding what is happening within your data. Measures of variation tell us how the data varies from end to end and/or within the middle of the dataset and because of this, some measures of spread help in identifying outliers.

For the following examples I took a non-random sample of animal lifespans, put them in order from shortest to longest lifespan. You’ll see the median is 11 years:


The range only considers the variation from the smallest to largest value in the dataset. Here, the animal’s lifespans range 30 years (or, 35 – 5 years). Unfortunately, range doesn’t give us much information about the variation within the datset.

Interquartile Range

Interquartile range, or IQR, is the range of the middle 50% of the dataset. In this situation, it represents the middle 50% of animal lifespans.

To find the IQR, the values in the dataset must first be ordered least to greatest with the median identified (as I did above). Since the median cuts the dataset in half, we then look for the middle value of the bottom half of the dataset (that is, the middle lifespan between the kangaroo and the cat). That represents the lower quartile, or Q1. Then look for the middle value of the top of the dataset, (that is, the middle value between the dog and the elephant). The second number represents the upper quartile, or Q3.

The interquartile range is found by subtracting Q3 – Q1, or 17.5 – 8.5 = 9 which tells me that the middle 50% of these animals’ lifespans range by 9 years. Unfortuantely, IQR only gives information about the spread of the middle of the dataset.

You can calculate the IQR in Excel using the QUARTILE function to find the first quartile and the third quartile, then subtracting like in the above example.

Ever build a box-and-whisker plot (boxplot)? The “box” portion represents the IQR. Here’s a how-to with more information.


One common method for calculating an outlier threshold in a dataset depends on the IQR. Once the IQR is calculated, it is then multiplied by 1.5. Find the low outlier threshold by subtracting the IQR*1.5 from Q1. Find upper outlier threshold by adding the IQR*1.5 to Q3. This is the method used to show outliers in box-and-whisker plots.

Standard Deviation

s is the standard deviation of the sample

Standard deviation measures the typical departure, or distance, of each data point from the mean. (Recall, the “mean” is just the average.) So ultimately, the calculation for standard deviation relies on the value of the mean.

The formula below specifically calculates the standard deviation of the sample. I wouldn’t worry too much about using this formula; however, understanding how standard deviation is calculated might help you understand what it calculates, so I’ll walk you through it:

sigma is the standard deviation of the population
  1. In the numerator within the parentheses, the mean is subtracted from each data point. As you can imagine, the mean is the center of the data so half of the resulting differences are negative (or 0), and the other half are positive (or 0). (Adding these differences up will always result in 0.)
  2. Those differences are then squared (making all values positive).
  3. The Greek uppercase letter Sigma in front of the parentheses means, “sum” — so all the squared differences are added up.
  4. Divide that value by the samples size (n) MINUS 1. Your resulting answer is the variance of the dataset.
  5. Since the variance is a squared measure, take the square root at the end. Now you have the standard deviation.

An easier way, of course, is to use Excel’s standard deviation functions for samples: STDEV or STDEV.S

Just like the mean, standard deviation is easily affected by outlying (extreme) values.


– The Stats Ninja


Several approaches are used to calculating the outlier threshold using standard deviations – which method is employed typically depends on the use case. Many software packages default to 3 standard deviations. If the outlier threshold is calculated using IQR (from above), 2.67 standard deviations mark that boundary.

Next Up: How to be the Life of the Party Part 2 breaks down measures of position, including percentiles and z-scores!

5 Ways to Keep Adult Learners Engaged

The year was 2002. It was the first time I ever stood in front of a classroom of “grown-ups”. The students didn’t know me or care who I was — a TA at LSU covering a College Algebra class. The topic was logarithms. Specifically, an introduction to logs as the inverse of an exponent. I may have been slightly older than the median age of those students and I was terrified, nervous, and profusely sweating.

Up until that moment, I thought deep content knowledge was the secret sauce of teaching. But in the 17 years of experiences that followed, I’ve learned how much MORE there is to teaching than merely knowing your stuff. Student buy-in is the key to student engagement and, ultimately, student learning.

As a corporate trainer I’ve found adults are no different from kids in how they learn and how they engage. It all depends on the trainer’s ability to read the room and adapt as needed.

I compiled the list below after 17 years of total instruction including college algebra and statistics, high school math and AP Statistics, and corporate training for data analysts. I’m sure I will update this list in the future, but at this point, reflecting on my own feedback and observing other trainers, these are the top points I find trainers miss.

Please note this list is not exhaustive and assumes you follow the basic tenants of instruction such as: knowing your audience, knowing your content, preparing x 10, taking breaks every 60 – 75 minutes, beginning promptly after a break, being approachable, avoiding excessive talk and rabbit holes, Rule of 3, minimizing powerpoint, summarizing major points, etc. So here you go – 5 ways to improve student engagement.

1. Be Adaptable.

“It is not the strongest of the species that survives, nor the most intelligent. It is the one that is most adaptable to change.”

– Charles Darwin

I’ve entered a classroom to discover the WiFi down. Many times. There have been a few unannounced fire drills, some medical emergencies, that time the projector bulb blew — all derailing my meticulously-planned lesson. But the show must go on!

If something goes wrong, keep calm but think on your feet. Focus on keeping the students engaged first. So if the students have working laptops and the only problem is a projector (or your laptop), get them started. Walk around the room teaching the concepts you’d planned to teach from the front. Ask the students questions, have them come up with solutions.

Tech completely down? Ask yourself, “What is the goal of this class?” It’s not easy to teach a tech-driven class with a whiteboard, but it can be done (and here’s hoping the WiFi will be up soon). In fact, if you teach a workshop using a software or only technology, I would urge you to get in the habit of adding in low-tech activities for those “just in case” moments.

Pro Tip: Oftentimes you can lead the students to an a-ha moment or two, then request IT support at the next break.

According to The Oxford Review, adaptability in the workplace is related to one’s emotional intelligence and emotional resilience. And, of course, mindset.

Lastly, being adapatable also means being coachable. Everyone gets frustrated from negative evaluations/feedback at times. But try to step back and ask yourself if you could have improved the delivery. Making tweaks to your performance based on student feedback can help YOU in the long run. Being coachable does NOT mean you give up confidence. You are the professional, but all great professionals learn from feedback and reflection.

2. Don’t Fake it.

It’s okay to admit you don’t know the answer to a question. Saying, “I’ll find out and get back to you” is not a weakness. What’s not okay is making up an answer. “Fake it til you make it” is NOT a mantra of teaching. Especially when you have Google.

“When you tell a lie, you steal someone’s right to the truth.”

– Khaled Hosseini

If you’re worried about questions, I recommend giving everyone sticky notes at the beginning of the class. Encourage students to ask questions. If a question comes up that is not relevant to the topic at hand OR if you don’t know the exact answer, ask the student to write down their question. Create a space on the wall for participants to stick these questions up (some trainers call this a “parking lot”) and on breaks, take some time to research and answer the questions. I would strongly recommend you DON’T take class time to do said research.

And oh the mistakes I’ve made when teaching. Some embarrassing. It happens. And it is important to own those mistakes, especially if you can turn it into a “teaching moment.” For example, I once observed a new math teacher square a binomial incorrectly. A COMMON mistake among students. So instead of (x+2)^2 = (x+2)*(x+2), she (without thinking about it) squared both terms, making (x+2)^2 = x^2 + 4. Whoops. A big mistake in the math world, but really not a big deal when she stopped herself, realizing her mistake, and laughed about it. Then explained that was an example of what NOT to do.

Squaring a binomial incorrectly may not be your mistake, but you will make one (probably many). But to err is human. And there is plenty of research out there to suggest an HONEST teacher is a TRUSTWORTHY teacher. People LIKE honest teachers, especially when it comes to their own flaws.

3. Use People’s Names.

“Go the extra mile. It’s never crowded.”

-Author Unknown

Names are powerful. Dale Carnegie once said, “A person’s name is, to him or her, the sweetest and most important sound in any language.” When someone takes the time to learn and use your name, you feel important. Which means using a person’s name in conversation is the quickest way to connect with them on a personal level — and therefore promotes positive classroom engagement.

Generally, people also enjoy talking about themselves. Which is a great way to learn their name. On the very first day, after I introduce myself, I give participants the opportunity to introduce themselves and say a few words. You probably already do this. And I use this as an opportunity to learn their name — I write it down then say their name aloud (so they hear it AND to help me remember). Creating a blank seating chart ahead of time is always helpful – this way I can jot down the name and an interesting fact while they speak, creating a reference for later in the course.

My friend and colleague Ryan Nokes remembers names much better than I do, impressing his classes by learning every name immediately! After preliminary introductions he says each person’s name, first to last person, and states their name (without notes). And then Ryan does it again at the start of the next day. People enjoy hearing their own names and are pleased when you remember them later

I teach hands-on courses and encourage constant interaction. When calling on students, I use their first name, careful not to just point to them. When talking to them one on one, I use their name. And by the way, please use the name they gave you. NOT their government name. FYI, I cringe when people call me, “Annamarie.”

Many articles have been published around the power of names. If you aren’t sure about the power of using a name, start here.

4. Move Around the Room.

“Nothing happens until something moves”

-Albert Einstein

Moving around the room, when done correctly, increases participant engagement.

When I teach, I rarely sit down. Moving around the room allows me to interact with each student one-on-one and check for their understanding. This proximity also allows the more reluctant talker/questioner to ask their burning question when they know the entire class won’t hear them. And, dare I say it: Moving around the room keeps you in control.

This is why you hear grade school teachers say they never sit down. K-12 teachers use physical proximity to manage their classrooms. Being interested in each student’s learning promotes positive behaviors and keep students on task. In the same way, walking around keeps adults out of their inbox. And you won’t ever hear me criticize a training participant about their email/phone use in class (despite it being a bit irritating — I mean, you DID sign up to be here) because when they expect me to move their direction, they self monitor and correct these behaviors themselves, often apologizing.

Note: I do try to give every group/person an equal amount of “attention” without lingering anywhere too long.

Educational research also promotes student movement around the room. So when delivering instruction, I like to create activities that make students/groups visualize data by hand – on a white board or big 3M sticky poster. Or even a post-it. “Around the room” activities could also include giving other groups positive feedback or presenting a new discovery in their data.

5. Seat People with Similar Experience-Levels Together.

When dealing with heterogeneous groups of participants.

“We are more powerful when we empower each other.”


After years of hoopla over the concept of “tracking students”, this tip might surprise you. How many times have you heard someone say, “Pair a low with a high?” And, while this strategy could work in certain courses and situations, it is, overall, an outdated practice.

Imagine. You have a grasp of the basics of a particular data visualization tool and use it weekly. A colleague in the same course has only installed the software that morning. Your instructor teams you up so you can “help” your colleague. How does this make you feel? At first, it might feel rewarding — you know the answers! However, in many situations the person doing the “helping” ends up feeling like they didn’t grow in their domain while the person being helped can eventually feel inadequate and frustrated.

No matter how well we market a course (“beginner”, “advanced”, etc) there will always be a heterogeneous group of abilities when I walk in to start instruction. And this is the way it always is — K12 or corporate training. So I can either roll my eyes and teach the outline as prescribed, pacing the middle of all abilities, or I can help all learners by differentiating my instruction a bit.

I’m not talking about group projects here — I only mean seating participants of like abilities near each other for an improved user experience. Of course in a training situation, this arrangement has more to do with experience levels — of which they can self-sort. I generally ask students “new” to the software to sit in the front, and others to sit behind them. That’s all that is usually needed.

But let’s look at the origins of this thought: When used appropriately, “flexible grouping” — pairing and grouping students based on need — can aid student learning on both ends of the experience spectrum. This can be homogeneous or heterogeneous groups. And how you utilize it matters. If you must pair high/low, do it only for a short time. (Because I’ve had students ask me, “Am I the dumb one or the smart one?”)

In the long run, research suggests pairing/seating students with similar abilities/experience in a domain (or software) engages all students. And if done correctly, actually improves their learning experience and accelerates their growth. How? If you’re already moving around the room (see #4 above), then it should make sense that you can tailor your instruction much easier to pairs/groups of similar background knowledge than if they are scattered around the room. Think about it — when you are helping a group of participants who are relatively new to the topic or software, you can give a “you try” practice problem to enrich or even accelerate the other group to work on their own, and vice versa. Peer pairing/grouping on similar experience levels also encourages those students to develop a deeper understanding of the topic together, rather than the back-and-forth waiting that occurs when unlike abilities are grouped.

Personally, I mix up my delivery — some whole group instruction, some partner work, maybe an activity in a group, and solo work. Pairing them up encourages dialog about the concepts while they work through a challenge. Groups can offer multiple points of view. Solo work helps the student think through the problem on their own. Since my classes are always hands-on I incorporate the process of I do, we do, you do. But I do start with seating like experience levels together.

Last Note

Being a teacher (or instructor, or coach) does require multiple skill sets including: entertainer, orchestra conductor, problem-solver, mind reader, therapist, referee, and cheerleader. However, promoting student engagement (teens and adults alike) goes beyond preparing a “fun lesson.” Student engagement results from student buy-in. And student buy-in results from the little things that create a positive atmosphere.

I’m going to add to this list over time. Do you have any suggestions on how you promote adult student engagement?

How Laser Tag Helped Students Learn About Data

How do you get a group of 15 to 18-year-old students interested in data prep and analysis? Why, you take them to play laser tag, of course!

That’s right, on a cold January day I loaded up two buses of teens and piloted them to an adventure at our local Stars and Strikes. And this is no small feat — this particular trip developed out of months of planning, and after years proclaiming that I will never ever ever ever EVER coordinate my own field trip for high school kids. I mean, you should SEE the stack of paperwork. And the level of responsibility itself made me anxious.

I’m a parent so I get it. And from a teacher’s point of view, many field trips aren’t worth the hassle.

So there I was, field trip money in one hand, clipboard in another: Imagine a caffeinated Tracy Flick. But thanks to the help of two parent chaperones and the AP Psychology teacher (Coach B), we ran the smoothest data-related field trip modern education has ever known.

What Does Laser Tag Have to do With Statistics?

Statistics textbooks are full of canned examples and squeaky clean data that often have no bearing on a students’ interests. For example, there is an oh-so-relatable exercise computing standard error for D-glucose contained in a sample of cockroach hindguts. In my experience I’ve learned when students can connect to the data, they are able to connect to the concept. We’re all like that, actually — to produce/collect our own data enables us to see what we otherwise would have missed.

(I can assure you confidence intervals constructed from D-glucose in coachroach hindguts did little for understanding standard error.)

The real world is made up of messy data. It’s full of unknowns, clerical errors, bias, unnecessary columns, confusing date formats, missing values; the list goes on. Laser Tag was suggested to me as a way to collect a “large” amount of data in a relatively short amount of time. And because of the size of the dataset, it required the student to input their own data — creating their own version of messy data complete with clerical errors. From there they’d have to make sense of the data, look for patterns, form hypotheses.

The Project

  • Students entered their data into a Google doc — you can find the complete data here.
  • Each partner team developed two questions for the data: One involving 1-variable analysis, another requiring bivariate analysis.
  • The duos then had to explore, clean, and analyze all 47 rows and 48 columns. At this point in the school year, students had been exposed to data up to about 50 rows, but never had they experienced “wide” data.
  • Analyses and presentations required a visualization, either using Excel or Tableau.

Partner projects lend to fantastic analyses, with half the grading

Playing the Games

Methodology: Each student was randomly assigned to a team using a random number generator. Teams of 5 played each other twice during the field trip. The teams were paired to play each other randomly. If, by chance, a team was chosen to play the same team twice, that choice would be ignored and another random selection would be made until a new team was chosen.

Before each game, I recorded which student wore which laser tag vest number. From the set-up room (see above picture), I could view which vest numbers were leading the fight and which team had the lead. It was entertaining. As the students (and Coach B — we needed one more player for even teams) finished their games, score cards were printed and I handed each student their own personal results. The words, “DON’T lose this” exited my lips often.

Upon our return to school (this only took a few hours, to the students’ dismay), results were already pouring the into the Google doc I’d set up ahead of time.

Teaching Tableau and Excel Skills

The AP Statistics exam is held every year in May, hosted by The College Board. On the exam, students are expected to use a graphing calculator but have no access to a computer or Google. Exactly the opposite of the real world.

Throughout the course, I taught all analysis first by hand, or using the TI-83/84. As students became proficient, I added time in the computer lab to teach basic skills using Excel and Tableau (assignments aligned to the curriculum while teaching skills in data analysis). It was my goal for students to have a general understanding of how to use these “real world” analytics tools while learning and applying AP Statistics curriculum.

After the field trip, we spent three days in the computer lab – ample time to work in Tableau and Excel with teacher guidance. Students spent time exploring the 48-column field trip dataset with both Excel and Tableau. They didn’t realize it, but by deciding which chart type to use for different variables, they were actually reviewing content from earlier in the year.

When plotting bivariate quantitative data, a scatterplot is often the go-to chart

Most faculty members had never heard of Tableau. At lunch one day I sat down with Coach B to demonstrate Tableau’s interface with our field trip dataset.

“What question would you ask this set of data?” I asked.

“A back shot is a cheap shot. I wonder who is more likely to take a cheap shot, males or females?”

So I proceeded to pull up a comparison and used box-and-whiskers plots to look for outliers. Within seconds, a large outlier was staring back at us within the pool of male students:

“Ha. I wonder who that was.” – Coach B

“That’s YOU.” – Me

From there, I created a tongue-in-cheek competitive analysis from the data:

Full color version found here.

Student Response

I’ve been teaching since 2004. Over the years, this was probably the most successful project I’ve seen come through my classroom. By “successful”, I’m talking the proportion of students who were able to walk outside of their comfort zone and into a challenging set of data, perform in-depth analyses, then communicate clear conclusions was much higher than in all previous years.

At the end of the year, after the AP Exam, after grades were all but inked on paper, students still talked excitedly about the project. I’d like to think it was the way I linked a fun activity to real-world analysis, though it most likely has to do with getting out of school for a few hours. Either way, they learned something valuable.

Univariate Analysis

One student, Abby, gave me permission to share her work adding, “This is the project that tied it all together. This was the moment I ‘got’ statistics.”

Interestingly, students were less inclined to suggest the female outlier of 2776 shots was a clerical mistake (which it was). I found there were two camps: Students who didn’t want to hurt feelings, and students who think outliers in the wild need no investigation. Hmmm.

Bivariate Analysis

For a group of kids new to communicating stats, I thought this was pretty good. We tweaked their wording (to be more contextual) as we dove into more advanced stats, but their analysis was well thought through.

What I Learned

When you teach, you learn.
Earlier I said the project was a success based on the students’ results. That’s only partially true; it was also a success because I grew as an educator. After years of playing by the rules I realized that sometimes you need to get outside your comfort zone. For me that was two-fold: 1) Sucking it up and planning a field trip and 2) Losing the old, tired TI-83 practice problems and teaching real-world analytics tools.

How to Decipher False Positives (and Negatives) with Bayes’ Theorem

Note: Before proceeding, a great recap of probability concepts can be found here, written by Paul Rossman. 

But First, Conditional Probability

When I teach conditional probability, I tell my students to pay close attention to the vertical line in the formula above. Whenever they see it, they must imagine the loud baritone behind-the-scenes announcer voice from Bill Nye saying, “GIVEN!”

This symbol | always indicates we assume the event that follows it has already occurred. The formula above, then, should be read: The probability event A will occur given event B has already occurred.

A simple example of conditional probability uses the ubiquitous deck of cards. From a standard deck of 52, what is the probability you draw an ace on the second draw if you know an ace has already been drawn (and left out of the deck) on the first draw?

Since a deck of 52 playing cards contains 4 aces, the probability of drawing the first ace is 4/52. But the probability of drawing an ace given the first card drawn was an ace is 3/51 — 3 aces left in the deck with 51 total cards remaining. Hence, conditional probability assumes another event has already taken place.

False Positives and False Negatives: What They’re Not

Tests are flawed.

According to MedicineNet, a rapid strep test from your doctor or urgent care has a 2% false positive rate. This means 2% of patients who do not actually have Group A streptococcus bacteria present in their mouth test positive for the bacteria. The rapid strep test also indicates a negative result in patients who do have the bacteria 5% of the time — a false negative.

Another way to look at it: The 2% “false positive” result indicates the test displays a true positive in 98% of patients. The 5% “false negative” result means the test displays a true negative in 95% of patients.

It’s common to hear these false positive/true positive results incorrectly interpreted. These rates do not mean the patient who tests positive for a rapid strep test has a 98% likelihood of having the bacteria and a 2% likelihood of not having it. And a negative result does not indicate one still has a 5% chance of having the bacteria.

Even more confusing, but important is the idea that while a 2% false positive does indicate that 2% of patients who do not have strep test positive, it does not mean that of all positives, 2% do have strep. There is more to consider in calculating those kinds of probabilities. Specifically, we would need to know how pervasive strep is for that population in order to come close to the actual probability that someone testing positive has the bacteria.

Enter: Bayes’ Theorem

Bayes’ Theorem considers both the population’s probability of contracting the bacteria and the false positives/negatives.

I know, I know — that formula looks INSANE. So I’ll start simple and gradually build to applying the formula – soon you’ll realize it’s not too bad.

Example: Drug Testing

Many employers require prospective employees to take a drug test. A positive result on this test indicates that the prospective employee uses illegal drugs. However, not all people who test positive actually use drugs. For this example, suppose that 4% of prospective employees use drugs, the false positive rate is 5%, and the false negative rate is 10%.

Here we’ve been given 3 key pieces of information:

  • The prevalence of drug use among these prospective employees, which is given as a probability of 4% (or 0.04). We can use the complement rule to find the probability an employee doesn’t use drugs: 1 – 0.04 = 0.96.
  • The probability a prospective employee tests positive when they did not, in fact, take drugs — the false positive rate — which is 5% (or 0.05).
  • The probability a prospective employee tests negative when they did, in fact, take drugs — the false negative rate — which is 10% (or 0.10).

It’s helpful to step back and consider the two things are happening here: First, the prospective employee either takes drugs, or they don’t. Then, they are given a drug test and either test positive, or they don’t.

I recommend a visual guide for these types of problems. A tree diagram helps you take these two pieces of information and logically draw out the unique possibilities.

Tree diagrams are also helpful to show us where to apply the multiplication principle in probability. For example, to find the probability a prospective employee didn’t take drugs and tests positive, we multiply P(no drugs) * P(positive) = (.96)*(.05) = 0.048.

An important note: The probability of selecting a potential employee who did not take drugs and tests negative is not the same as the probability an employee tests negative GIVEN they did not take drugs. In the former, we don’t know if they took drugs or not; in the latter, we know they did not take drugs – the “given” language indicates this prior knowledge/evidence.

What’s the probability someone tests positive?

We can also use the tree diagram to calculate the probability a potential employee tests positive for drugs.

A potential employee could test positive when they took drugs OR when they didn’t take drugs. To find the probabilities separately, multiply down their respective tree diagram branches:

Using probability rules, “OR” indicates you must add something together. Since one could test positive in two different ways, just add them together after you calculate the probabilities separately:

P(positive) = 0.048 + 0.036 = 0.084

Given a positive result, what is the probability a person doesn’t take drugs?

Which brings us to Bayes’ Theorem:

Let’s find all of the pieces:

  • P(positive | no drugs) is merely the probability of a false positive = 0.05
  • P(no drugs) = 0.96
  • So we already calculated the numerator above when we multiplied 0.05*0.96 = 0.048
  • We also calculated the denominator: P(positive) = 0.084

which simplifies to


This means, if we know a potential employee tested positive for drug use, there is a 57.14% probability they don’t actually take drugs — which is MUCH HIGHER than the false positive rate of 0.05. In other words, if a potential employee (in this population with 4% drug use) tests positive for drug use, the probability they don’t take drugs is 57.14%

How is that different from a false positive? A false positive says, “We know this person doesn’t take drugs, but the probability they will test positive for drug use is 5%.” While if we know they tested positive, the probability they don’t take drugs is 57%.

Why is this probability so large? It doesn’t seem possible! Yet, it takes into account the likelihood a person in the population takes drugs, which is only 4%.

In math terms:

P(positive | no drugs) = 0.05 while P(no drugs | positive) = 0.5714

Which also means that if a potential employee tests positive, the probability they do indeed take drugs is lower than what you might think. You can find this probability by taking the complement of the last calculation: 1 – 0.5714 = 0.4286. OR, recalculate using the formula:

Now You Try: #DataQuiz

Back in October I posted a #DataQuiz to Twitter, with a Bayesian twist. Can you calculate the answer using this tutorial without looking at the answer (in tweet comments)?


  • Draw out the situation using a tree diagram
  • What happens first? What happens second?
  • What is “given”?

Next Up: Business Applications

Stay tuned! Paul Rossman has a follow-up post that I’ll link to when it’s ready. He’s got some brilliant use case scenarios with application in Tableau.